I have never written a good first draft, and I have stopped expecting to. What I have learned instead is to treat the first draft as a map drawn in the dark: roughly right about where things are, badly wrong about distances, and full of places marked here be something.
Revision is the walk that follows. You go back over the same ground in daylight and discover that the river you drew is a ditch, that the hill is a cliff, and that the path you thought led home actually ends at a fence. None of this is failure. It is simply what maps made in the dark are like.
Three walks through every draft
- The long walk. Read the whole piece in one sitting, aloud if you can, without fixing anything. Only notice where you get bored and where you get lost.
- The surveyor's walk. Go paragraph by paragraph and ask what each one does. If you cannot say it in a sentence, the paragraph does not know either.
- The evening walk. Read slowly for sound. This is where sentences are shortened, rhythms are mended and the last weak words are taken out.

The comparison is not only a metaphor. Many of my best revisions have happened on actual walks, with the draft folded in a coat pocket and a pencil that kept breaking. Movement loosens something. A sentence that refused to behave at the desk will often rearrange itself somewhere near the third gate on the hill path.
If you are stuck on a piece of writing, I recommend both kinds of walking. Print it out, put on your shoes, and go and look at the ground you mapped in the dark.
