New The Salt Orchard, a new novel, is out now

Writing Life

Notes on Revision: The Fourth Draft

Manuscript pages marked in red ink scattered beside a cup of coffee

People often ask how many drafts a novel takes. The honest answer is: as many as it takes to stop lying. The Salt Orchard needed four.

The first draft was three hundred pages of me finding out what the story was about. The second cut a whole point of view. The third moved the ending to the middle. The fourth, the one you can now read, was mostly about trust: trusting the reader to notice what I no longer needed to say.

What I cut

  • A seventy-page flashback to 1952
  • A talking dog (I am not sorry)
  • Every sentence beginning with 'Suddenly'
  • The prologue, twice
  • Two weddings and one funeral
  • Eleven thousand words about apple varieties

Revision is not fixing what is broken. It is finding out what the book has been trying to be all along.

If you are in the middle of your own revision, take heart. The pages you cut are not wasted. They are the scaffolding the finished book stood on while it was being built.