Gear

Five Rain Shells, One Very Wet Autumn

A hiker in a blue rain jacket walking along a ridge in heavy rain

Waterproof jackets are the most-asked-about kit in the club. So this autumn five members each took a different shell on every walk for two months, from drizzle to the kind of sideways rain that finds every gap.

We are not naming brands: models change every year. Instead, here is what made the difference between a good shell and a damp one.

TypeWeightDry after 4 hrs rain?Our rating
Three-layer, heavyweight520 gYes★★★★★
Three-layer, lightweight340 gMostly★★★★☆
Two-and-a-half-layer290 gDamp at the cuffs★★★☆☆
Two-layer with lining610 gYes, but sweaty★★★☆☆
Budget poncho230 gNo, in wind★★☆☆☆

What actually mattered

  • A hood that turns with your head, with a stiff peak.
  • Pit zips for climbing, because breathable fabric has limits.
  • Long enough to sit on, especially for lunch stops.
  • Cuffs that close tight over gloves.

The heavyweight three-layer jacket won on dryness, but most testers would choose the lightweight one for everyday walking. Whatever you buy, re-proof it each season: a tired outer face lets water soak in and makes any jacket feel wet.

★★★★☆ Lightweight three-layer: our pick for most walkers